« Sherrod Brown leads Josh Mandel by 15 points | Main | No hope for Obama in Mississippi »

November 10, 2011

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Gerald

MS is the poorest state in the nation and these clowns fall over themselves to support candidates who would cut federal aid to MS. I'd love to meet some of these folks with annual incomes of less than $30K, no health insurance and net worth of less than ten grand as they explain why it is vital that we cut the estate tax, the marginal rate, and the corporate income tax, even while imposing a 9% sales tax on poor people.

Honestly, if these people want to be exploited, why fight it? Let them be plucked clean like a spring chicken. As long as the guy exploiting and impoverishing them wears a US flag pin on his lapel and likes women, they don't seem to mind.

Noah

@Gerald
Poor voting against their self interest is certainly a mystery to a lot of Democrats. I think Democrats need to understand that there are a lot of reason why poor in the country would even vote republicans. Some are living in the rural area and cherish their right to bear arms more than anything. Some are just do not benefit from the welfare program provided by the federal government. Ever heard of how many people don't even know that they get a tax cut the Democrats proposed because people don't pay close attention to them and the white house and the Obama administration are poor at messaging unlike the Republicans. I think the derogatory language many Democrats including you express to the poor in this country will not advance the progressive causes. We need to listen and understand by educating and better communicating with our supposedly Republican voting enemies.
http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2011/jul/19/stop-patronising-poor-americans

George

"As long as the guy exploiting and impoverishing them wears a US flag pin on his lapel and likes women, they don't seem to mind."

No! As long as the white guy exploiting and impoverishing them wears a US flag pin on his lapel and likes only white women, they don't seem to mind. They also dont seem to mind as long as the black black guy exploiting and impoverishing them wears a US flag pin on his lapel and likes only black women, they dont seem to mind. Remember a March 2011 PPP poll where 46% of GOP pimary voters opposed interracial dating or marriage? PPP never released the results of what the white dem voters thought. To make the long story short, I think Herman Cain would have been ok as long as he runs against a black man and is married to a black woman. How the sex scandals involving white women play out will be a matter of great deal of interest!

George

"I think the derogatory language many Democrats including you express to the poor in this country will not advance the progressive causes. We need to listen and understand by educating and better communicating with our supposedly Republican voting enemies."

No! The country is changing. Read Glen Bolger's piece on Crystal Ball. The poor whites are smaller and smaller proportion of the voting population..they should no longer be part of the Dem coalition...call me arrogant, but that is the reality. I did not shed a tear when the miners died in the blast in WV. They voted for the GOP...and actions should have consequences.

Gerald

I wasn't derogating the poor. Most poor people do not fall over themselves to support Herman Cain and Michelle Bachmann. I am talking about a subgroup of poor, working class, and middle class people in the Midwest and South who appear to vote consistently in a manner that is directly contrary to their economic interest. You show respect for such people by speaking with them, to them, and about them as if they are responsible adults, not special education students. They don't need pseudo-psychotherapy and they don't need a condescending listening session. Treat them as adults and tell them that they are being played for fools.

Incidentally, the problem is not that votes are cast on social issues. It is perfectly justifiable in some cases to cast a vote on that basis. For example, abortion is a perfectly legitimate social issue on which to cast a vote, even for a candidate who might otherwise work against your financial interests.

The problem is not that voters have made an informed, conscious decision to elevate the salience of a particular social issue over one or more economic issues. The problem is that there are so many low-information voters who, being unable to parse through issues like the estate tax, deficit reduction, and credit default swaps, simply default to the easily-understood social issues, often trivial social issues that have absolutely no bearing on their lives. Low information voters who don't default to social issues are also far more susceptible to believe whatever ridiculous spin is put out on the economy. That is why you have plenty of people in MS who are convinced that the economic meltdown of 2008 was caused by a 1977 federal law that proposed modest efforts to expand home ownership. Government was the problem and the solution is to unshackle the future AIGs and Lehmans from their regulatory chains.
All it took was one spinmeister to dream that up and a built-in audience of low-information voters was ready to lap it up.

jeff

Noah: I don't think its so much that the white house and the democrats are poor at messaging. I don't think people understand that the media doesn't spread the message that the white house tends to send. Rather they spend more time misinforming and focusing on the republicans.

Dustin Ingalls

"Remember a March 2011 PPP poll where 46% of GOP pimary voters opposed interracial dating or marriage? PPP never released the results of what the white dem voters thought."

Yes we did. http://publicpolicypolling.typepad.com/pdf/2011/PPP_Release_GAMSNC_0421.pdf

Jay

Why don't you turn this around and ask why are so many rich white people in the suburbs around the big northern cities are voting for Democrats? It's certainly not in their interest to do so, especially with Obama in the White House. The point I am making is that not all voters vote in their financial self interest. Many other factors come into play and one should not assume that voters are completely blind to what they are doing.

Daniel

Gerald, they don't want your self-pity, they want to make it in life by themselves. What's the problem with that?

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been saved. Comments are moderated and will not appear until approved by the author. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until the author has approved them.

PPP POLLS BY YEAR: 2006-2013

Our Final 2012 Polls

WE’RE HIRING A SALES PROFESSIONAL

Public Policy Polling (PPP) is seeking an experienced sales professional to lead and develop our politically-based business and expand our services to new markets.
Download Job Opening Details

CONTACT US

Public Policy Polling
2912 Highwoods Blvd., Suite 201
Raleigh, NC 27604
Phone: 888.621.6988

Questions or Comments?
Email Us

TESTIMONIALS

NPR Public Policy Polling was profiled by NPR as “one of the most prolific polling outfits in the country.” Read more...

The Wall Street Journal ranked PPP as one of the top swing state pollsters in the country during the last Presidential election.

WSJ Graphic

RECENT POSTS

Categories

HIRE PPP

Dean Debnam Dean Debnam
Public Policy Polling CEO

PPP is best known for putting out highly accurate polling on key political races across the country, but we also do affordable private research for candidates and organizations.  Why pay tens of thousands of dollars for a survey when one of the most reliable companies in the nation can do it for less?"

Learn more about working
with PPP for your next project >

FOLLOW US

Facebook Facebook
Twitter Twitter
RSS Feed RSS Reader
Email Sign up: New Polling Data email